
The Federal Character Commission v. Nigerian Customs: A Constitutional Awakening
By Charles Ude, Esq.
Legal Practitioner and Author
charlesude2014@gmail.com
The Court Case That Shook Abuja
On 12 November 2026, something happened in Abuja that had not happened in years. The Federal Character Commission (FCC) filed a four-count criminal charge at the Federal High Court against the Nigeria Customs Service and its Comptroller-General, Bashir Adewale Adeniyi. The suit number is FHC/ABJ/CR/772/2026.
Let that sink in. A constitutional body was taking a federal agency to court, not for tea and consultations, but for criminal non-compliance.
The charges are straightforward:
- Failure to submit a recruitment roster.
- Failure to allow FCC monitors to observe recruitment exercises.
- Ignoring a lawful suspension order.
- Refusing to provide the qualification criteria used for recruitment.
The Comptroller-General himself is accused of having “recklessly, negligently, or deliberately acquiesced” in these acts. In plain language, the Commission is saying he either looked the other way or actively encouraged the defiance.
The timeline tells its own story:
· 25 March 2026: The FCC asked for the recruitment roster. Customs said nothing.
· 14 September – 7 October 2026: Customs went ahead with recruitment stages without inviting FCC monitors. Business as usual.
· 23 October 2026: The FCC issued a suspension order. Customs allegedly ignored it.
· 30 January – 20 October 2026: The FCC kept asking for the qualification standards used. Customs kept quiet.
This case matters for one simple reason. The question is no longer whether the FCC can prove that Customs discriminated against anyone. The question is whether Customs can show that it cooperated with constitutional oversight at all. Under Section 14(3) of the Federal Character Commission Act, refusing to cooperate is itself an offence. Section 15 spells out the penalties. It really is that simple.
The FCC Is Not a Rubber Stamp
The FCC’s authority comes directly from Section 153(1) of the 1999 Constitution. The Third Schedule sets out its mandate. The Federal Character Commission (Establishment, etc.) Act, Cap. F7, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria 2004, gives it the teeth to enforce that mandate.
One of those teeth is the power to prosecute heads of ministries, departments, and agencies who refuse to comply with the federal character principle. This is not a favour the Commission does when it feels like it. It is a duty. A statutory obligation.
FCC Executive Chairman Hurayat Motunrayo Omidiran put it plainly:
“The Commission will not abandon its statutory duties because of institutional pressure, administrative inconvenience, or the status of any public officer.”
Honestly, that statement should be framed and hung in every federal agency in this country. Right where everyone can see it.
Customs Is Not Alone
Before anyone thinks this is only about Customs, let us be clear. The Nigeria Railway Service, the Central Bank of Nigeria, the Nigerian National Petroleum Company, the National Revenue Service, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, the Department of State Services — they have all, at one time or another, hidden their recruitment processes from public view. The excuses are always the same: institutional sensitivity, operational peculiarities, national security.
But the Constitution does not recognise any of these exemptions. No institution is too powerful, too sensitive, or too important to escape constitutional accountability.
The South-East: Exclusion Without Remedy
If you want to see what happens when constitutional safeguards exist only on paper, look at the South-East.
In March 2026, FCC Commissioner Peter Ogbonna Eze said publicly that the participation rate of South-East youths in recruitment into the Nigeria Police Force and other security agencies was significantly lower than that of other regions. This is not new. During the last administration of the late President Buhari, the entire South suffered from this imbalance, with the South-East being worse off. Under the current Tinubu regime, it is my opinion that the situation has not only worsened for the South-East but that the region is now being selectively targeted. The recruitment data from these agencies will confirm it.
But there is a second tragedy here, and it is one that we in the South-East rarely talk about honestly. The region has suffered from a lack of effective institutional advocacy. The labour movement has largely ignored complaints of pre-employment discrimination. Civil society groups have preferred advocacy to enforcement. Regional organisations have often embraced narratives of victimhood rather than supporting mechanisms capable of delivering measurable change.
The FCC’s action could change this. If the Commission succeeds, the recruitment data that emerge will either confirm allegations of exclusion or disprove them. Either way, evidence will replace speculation. And once we have evidence, we can begin to talk about real corrective measures.
The Courts Have Already Spoken
Nigerian courts have consistently affirmed the constitutional prohibition against discrimination. The National Industrial Court has repeatedly relied on Section 42(1) of the Constitution, which prohibits subjecting any Nigerian citizen to disabilities or restrictions based on community, ethnic group, place of origin, sex, religion, or political opinion.
In the Abia State case, the court declared unconstitutional and void a civil service circular that transferred employees on the basis of their “non-indigene” status. In the Taraba State case, the court ordered the state government to pay over ₦108 million in damages to eighteen employees who were excluded from absorption into the civil service because they were classified as non-indigenes.
These decisions establish an unmistakable legal principle: excluding qualified individuals from employment or employment-related opportunities on the basis of origin or indigene status is actionable, compensable, and potentially punishable under Nigerian law.
The Silence of Labour and Civil Society Is Unconscionable
The silence of the Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) and the Trade Union Congress (TUC) is particularly troubling.
One of the fundamental responsibilities of organised labour is the protection of workers’ rights, including the right of prospective workers to equal employment opportunities. Yet there appears to be no public record of either organisation issuing a statement or taking any visible action regarding the FCC’s prosecution of the Nigeria Customs Service.
Civil society organisations have been similarly absent. Groups such as CDGPA supported the House of Representatives’ investigation into the Nigeria Railway Service’s alleged secret recruitment exercise in July 2026. CISLAC publicly pledged technical support to the FCC. But these interventions remained within the realm of advocacy and parliamentary oversight. When the issue moved from advocacy to actual enforcement through criminal prosecution, public support largely disappeared.
The silence of South-East and Southern-based organisations such as Ohanaeze Ndigbo and the Southern/Middle Belt Leaders’ Forum is particularly striking. These groups have often been vocal in condemning electoral injustice and security abuses. Yet when the FCC sought judicial intervention to compel Customs to release data that could help verify allegations of regional exclusion, they remained silent.
The explanation may be uncomfortable but it is unavoidable: narratives of victimhood can be sustained indefinitely, while successful enforcement demands evidence, accountability, and measurable outcomes.
Silence in such circumstances is not neutrality. It is complicity.
The National Assembly Has Failed Woefully
The FCC has shown what institutional commitment to constitutional governance looks like. The National Assembly should take note and reflect on its own shortcomings.
Legislative oversight has increasingly become ineffective. Public hearings conclude with resolutions that are rarely implemented. Committee reports are submitted and forgotten. An institution possessing both constitutional authority and budgetary leverage has repeatedly failed to hold federal agencies accountable for violations of constitutional principles.
It has instead fallen to the FCC, itself a constitutional creation, to do what Parliament should have done long ago: bring a federal agency before a court of law for treating constitutional obligations as optional.
The FCC’s approach provides a model worthy of emulation:
Investigate. Document. Enforce.
Enforcement Cannot Be a One-Man Show
Good intentions alone will not sustain enforcement. If the FCC is left to fight this battle alone, agencies such as Customs, the CBN, NNPC, NRS, EFCC, and DSS possess sufficient legal and administrative resources to prolong litigation through years of procedural manoeuvring. They know how to wait people out.
Civil society cannot replace legal advocacy, but it can raise the political and social costs of non-compliance. Labour organisations should place pre-employment discrimination at the centre of their agenda and establish independent fair-recruitment monitoring networks. Civil society groups should publish a Federal Character Compliance Index, measuring agencies according to:
· Recruitment-data disclosure rates;
· Cooperation with FCC monitoring;
· Compliance with constitutional directives; and
· State-by-state distribution balance.
Likewise, organisations in the South and South-East must move beyond merely speaking for victims and become active partners in enforcement. The recruitment data that Customs is now being compelled to disclose may provide precisely the evidence needed to substantiate longstanding allegations of exclusion.
A New Standard of Accountability
The FCC’s decision to prosecute establishes a new standard for federal governance: constitutional compliance is not optional.
The Nigeria Customs Service, the Nigerian National Petroleum Company, the Central Bank of Nigeria, the National Revenue Service, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, the Department of State Services, and every other federal institution must understand that the Federal Character Commission is not a ceremonial body. It is a constitutional watchdog with both the authority and the willingness to act.
One prosecution does not transform a system. The FCC’s charge sheet represents a beginning, not a conclusion. But if organised labour and civil society continue to remain absent, they will be sending a dangerous message to federal agencies: that constitutional violations carry little practical consequence and that Section 14(3) of the Constitution may continue to be treated as a dead letter.
Qualified job seekers from the South-East do not need more expressions of sympathy. They need transparent recruitment processes. They need FCC monitors present at every recruitment exercise. They need recruitment rosters opened to public scrutiny. And when agencies attempt to reserve opportunities for “their own people,” they need labour organisations, civil society groups, journalists, and lawyers prepared to respond with litigation, investigation, and public accountability.
The FCC has taken the first step.
The rest of us must now do our part.
Support the FCC. Demand transparency. End the silence.
CU November 2026
